General Petraeus’s Remarks Require Much Reflection by Our Society

I remember the day I found out I got into West Point. My mom actually showed up in the hallway of my high school and waited for me to get out of class. She was bawling her eyes out and apologizing that she had opened up my admission letter. She wasn’t crying because it had been her dream for me to go there. She was crying because she knew how hard I’d worked to get in, how much I wanted to attend, and how much I wanted to be an infantry officer. I was going to get that opportunity. That same day two of my teachers took me aside and essentially told me The following: “David, you’re a smart guy. You don’t have to join the military. You should go to college, instead.”

I could easily write a theme defending WestPoint and the military as I did that day, explaining that USMA is an elite institution, that separate from that it is actually statistically much harder to enlist in the military than it is to get admitted to college, that serving the nation is a challenge that all able-bodied men should at least consider for a host of reasons, but I won’t.

What I will say is that when a 16 year-old kid is being told that attending West Point is going to be bad for his future then there is a dangerous disconnect in America, and entirely too many Americans have no idea what kind of burdens our military is bearing. In World War II, 11.2% of the nation served in four (4) years. During the Vietnam era, 4.3% served in twelve (12) years. Since 2001, only 0.45% of our population has served in the Global War on Terror. These are unbelievable statistics. Overtime, fewer and fewer people have shouldered more and more of the burden and it is only getting worse. Our troops were sent to war in Iraq by a Congress consisting of 10% veterans with only one person having a child in the military. Taxes did not increase to pay for the war. War bonds were not sold. Gas was not regulated. In fact, the average citizen was asked to sacrifice nothing, and has sacrificed nothing unless they have chosen to out of the goodness of their hearts. The only people who have sacrificed are the veterans and their families. The volunteers. The people who swore an oath to defend this nation.

You stand there, deployment after deployment and fight on. You’ve lost relationships, spent years of your lives in extreme conditions, years apart from kids you’ll never get back, and beaten your body in a way that even professional athletes don’t understand. Then you come home to a nation that doesn’t understand. They don’t understand suffering. They don’t understand sacrifice. They don’t understand why we fight for them. They don’t understand that bad people exist. They look at you like you’re a machine – like something is wrong with you. You are the misguided one – not them.

When you get out, you sit in the college classrooms with political science teachers that discount your opinions on Iraq and Afghanistan because YOU WERE THERE and can’t understand the macro issues they gathered from books, because of your bias. You watch TV shows where every vet has PTSD and the violent strain at that. Your Congress is debating your benefits, your retirement, and your pay, while they ask you to do more. But the amazing thing about you is that you all know this. You know your country will never pay back what you’ve given up. You know that the populace at large will never truly understand or appreciate what you have done for them. Hell, you know that in some circles, you will be thought as less than normal for having worn the uniform. Just that decision alone makes you part of an elite group.

“Never in the field of human conflict has so much been owed by so many to so few.” -Winston Churchill

Thank you to the 11.2% and 4.3% who have served and thanks to the 0.45% who continue to serve our Nation.

General David Petraeus West Point Class 1974

Comments

  1. Jim Wilson says:

    General Petraeus didn’t write this. Nick Palmisciano, President at Ranger Up, did. (http://rhinoden.rangerup.com/i-wrote-this/). Probably doesn’t change how you feel about the article, but I would recommend you do a better job of source checking before posting stuff if you want to develop a good reputation.

  2. Matt says:

    Hey Admin,

    This isn’t written by Patraeus. It was written by Nick Palmisciano, the co-founder of Rangerup.com

    Please give Nick the credit he deserves for such a touching statement.

    http://www.rangerup.com/the45.html

    http://www.snopes.com/politics/soapbox/045percent.asp

    • Marilynn says:

      This is a wonderful essay. I have let my friends who sent me the email stating Gen. P. wrote this that they are wrong and referred them to Google to verify.

      Let’s give credit where credit is due – to a brave Marine.

  3. william Joseph (Joe) Burner II says:

    Folks, Just sent this MSG to a number of old friends in the Pentagon…GEN officers…Be careful what you do on policies dealing with guidance from the Congress and the Senate. Sir you’re a Soldier’s Soldier and these fools are taking our Military down too far. We cannot let it happen Sir. This is America home of the Free and the Brave. The Book “Throw Them All Out” hits it on the nail in the last two chapters; 9-10. Sir get the book and please read it. I read this book with a grain of Salt. It’s on both sides and has been going on for a long time. George Washington resigned his commission when they wanted to make him king. 4 years later he became our President. Thomas Jefferson left the White House with his hands empty. Abraham Lincoln made the statement, ” Nearly all men can stand adversity, but if you want to test a man’s Character, give him power” Federal list # 57 States, ” If this spirit is ever corrupted to the point that it will tolerate a law which does not apply to both the legislature and the people, then the people will be prepared to tolerate anything but Liberty” Soldiers are the most important thing we have Sir. Protect them and help keep this nation free.

  4. william Joseph (Joe) Burner II says:

    GM will soon be a China Company. China is building up the DLA their Army like Crazy. They are stepping on their neighbors and they are a communist government. We are in hock to them and the Dollar is falling. We must get our industry back into this country and step on all of the Socialism on going in this country. God bless you all. Our founding Fathers are rolling over in their grave the way this country is being ran today. The mountain is high but we have to keep climbing to get back to the top……never give up. This is America the home of the Free and the Brave.

  5. william Joseph (Joe) Burner II says:

    All,

    Please read “Throw Them All Out” Do not let the title fool you. Get the book and read Charter 9 and 10, the last two chapters in the book if you do not want to read the entire book. I am an old Soldier, Combat in Vietnam 1968, and Combat support in 1972. Gave Army 34 years, Retired Officer, Worked 8 Years as a contractor with L3 and now work with SEC still providing for our soldiers and Service Members. We need to take this country back. I’m fighting with 40 Senators and 100 delegates in the Virginia State Capital to pass HB 130 the bill to stop taxing Service members Retirement pay. There are 20 States that to not tax retirement pay. Stand up for your Country and make sure you VOTE this year

  6. Joe Burner says:

    If Sue is correct this needs to be corrected ASAP. Our Country is going downhill fast. I am a Patriot and gave my country 34 years. I was in Combat in 1968 in Vietnam and in Combat Support in Vietnam in 1971. I’m an old War Horse still doing for my country and our Veterans. 8 years as a contractor with L3 and now a CS with the Software Engineer Command (SEC). I’m in a fight right now with the State of Virginia Capital to stop taxing our retired Veterans. Read the Book “Throw them all out” it’s on both sides in both parties. Read the Book “the Naked Communist” and the 45 rules that in the book Page 258-262. This is ongoing in our Country today. We need to stand up and take this country back!! God Bless you all.

    Joe

  7. Mathew says:

    WHILE I’M SURE THAT ALL OF YOU ARE VERY PROUD OF THIS LETTER, IT WAS IN FACT NOT WRITTEN BY GENERAL PETRAEUS!!! IT WAS WRITTEN BY NICK PALMISCIANO OF RANGERUP.COM. PLEASE GIVE THIS PROPER ATTRIBUTION TO HIM, AS THIS GREAT ESSAY DESERVES TO HAVE THE TRUE AUTHOR RECOGNIZED. THE LINK I ADDED TO MY POST SHOULD TAKE YOU TO HIS REPOST CORRECTING THE MASSES AND EXPLAINING HOW HE GOT TO THE POINT OF WRITING THE ARTICLE. SOFA, PLEASE REWORK THIS ARTICLE TO GIVE THE AUTHOR HIS PROPER CREDIT!!!!!

  8. Sue Crain says:

    Yes, a great speech! However, it was not written by General Petreaus. It was written by Nick Palmisciano , the President of Ranger Up, West Point Class of 98, and an Army vet. He wrote this and posted it to his Ranger Up website, it was copied and printed in the Army Times and from there it seems to have been picked up and been misquoted all over the place. Nick is trying to get the word out so it is not any type of embarrassment to General Petreaus!

  9. John Holland says:

    As one of the many Americans that have NOT served, let me (may I be the first or the last to) say THANK YOU !

  10. John Doe says:

    Can someone please confirm when General Petraeus gave this speech? This is an excellent speeech! However, I have not found any reference to who/when presented this speech.

    • Dan says:

      Same concerns. Are we sure this wasn’t just some rando trying to piggy back on a popular name?

    • Mathew says:

      It was NOT General Petraeus! It was a man named Nick, and his essay was taken as reported while being attributed to many incorrect people like Gen. Petraeus. Read the article to the link I posted. It clears it up!

  11. PHILIP ANGE, says:

    WELL SAID GENERAL..WELL SAID. THANK YOU, SIR!!
    USN RET & DAMN PROUD TO HAVE SERVED!!

  12. Matthew Michels says:

    In the late 60′s and early 70′s shallow-minded Americans in liberal institutions like academia behaved in a deplorable manner to servicemen and women upon their return home. These noble individuals deserve recognition for protecting “liberal thinking” without retribution or persecution in America. I graduated from high school in 1972 and had I been in a situation in which a serviceman or woman was being mistreated, I would have acted to defend and protect him or her. But that does not mean that I approved of reported incidents in the media. There was never an opportunity to express my disapproval. If the Internet had been available then, media would have received emails from me.

    Thirty years later, driving on the local highway in heavy traffic, there was a landscape timber laying in the road. Thankfully no accidents occured and the thing bounced around until it landed in the hazard lane. The highway patrol office exit was immediately ahead so I exited so I could let them know about the hazard on the road.

    As I walked in the office, I immediately noticed a young man sitting in the chairs next to the window. I looked at him and smiled, he smiled back but I was running late getting home so I hurriedly told the DPS person about the situation and as I exited the office I again made eye-contact with the young man, smiled and nodded at him as I left. Upon entering the office and seeing him, I immediately realized he was a serviceman. I remember thinking while I looked in his eyes “thank you so much, God Bless You, and please Lord make sure he gets this job”. But I didn’t say anything.

    To this day I think about that young man and have so much regret that I didn’t say something.

    To the young man sitting in the DPS office on Crest Drive in Waco around 2007 or 2008, “I apologize for not taking the time to thank you. There has NEVER been anything more important in my life than shaking the hand of someone who has bravely defended my right to freedom while willingly sacrificing so much personally.”

    Mrs. Matthew Michels

  13. Eduardo Cruz says:

    I love the article by the general. It is so true. But wasn’t president Bush that told everyone to go on and keep shopping. I know most of you wannabes forget about that.
    Also, it was president Bush and the republicans that tried to do away with combat pay while I was under fire. Forgot that one too, I bet.

    And this guy, Ryan Zinke, complains about the president politicizing bin laden kill, please, every president takes credit for whatever happens under his watch. Remember “Mission Accomplished” ? It is this state senator that is trying to get political traction by being all over the news with seal team 6 history, what a hypocrite! Shame on him.
    JSOC was told to cool it down with all the news stories about the raid. Typical Navy recruiting jargon. You haven’t heard who flew the operators there? Or what other operators provided rear and exit support?
    For the one of you that know military ops, sofd-d (CAG) is what, in Hawaii?
    So senator, stop your seal team 6 stuff. It is unbecoming of an officer and a true spec ops warrior!

    • Anthony Kirk says:

      Cruz,
      I can’t read Zinke’s minds but, I think part of the point is it was a combined effort by all branches over many years to get bin laden..Sure, even back during MACSOG in my day, not discussing what you did or where you went was absolute. I agree, all POTUS take credit for successful military missions but usually they thank the men and women of the armed forces NOT themselves over and over and over…+ drop the name of a secret special forces unit..

      I did not agree with POTUS G.W. Bush and his methods of taking our country into IRAQ..I also felt that Rumsfeld was about the most ignorant Sec Def ever….The IRAQ land mass and population warranted at least twice as many troopers as BUSH and Rumsfeld agreed on. That is why his mission accomplished was so lame..

      Additionally, you got to ease up Cruz, I doubt many Vets of IRAQ feel Bush did what was necessary to win and protect their asses at the same time…No armored Humvees was about the dumbest thing along with Rumsfeld constantly saying everything was going as planned.

      Just another Brother in Arms
      1967-1968 tours in the jungle living the dream

  14. Virgil Dennis says:

    Thank you General for writing what all Vets have known but never could articulate as effectively.

    I enlisted in the Army at 17 and after a year of jungle warfare training with the 11th LIB in Hawaii our brigade was shipped out to Viet-Nam in late 1967. I turned 18 on the ship and by the time my tour was complete I got my first leave in two years. When I was in country I took no R&R and many of the others did the same; we did not want to leave our brothers short handed and always felt a responsibility to watch each others back.

    The way we were treated upon our return is a black mark in our country’s history; being spit at in the airport and called “baby killer” was our welcome home message (and it did happen to me in San Francisco). It wasn’t until late 2010 that someone said “thank you for your service” to me, but it had a profound effect on me. At least now I don’t skirt the subject or hide the fact that I’m a Viet-Nam combat veteran.

  15. Anthony Kirk says:

    I faced similar discouragement going into the military in 1967 from my father….He did not believe in the war nor any part of why someone, especially a son, would join at that point in time…When I returned from Vietnam I only had a high school diploma. I applied for a job in Flint, Michigan at General Motors. I was surprised when I was offered a salary position not having a college degree. General Motors policy included the Veterans Pref Act so, I started my employment as a 5th level truck dispatcher @ $650.00 per month and was very happy…General Motors paid for my education back then along with many others. I worked hard and smart throughout my 34 years with GM and accepted a early retirement package in Feb 2004. I was a mid level manager and was having issues with the folks coming direct into mid level and above positions directly out of college. It seemed to them, mostly all MBA’s, that what they learned in the classroom trumped whatever knowledge I had gained in 34 year in the auto industry.

    I have watched as GM went into the arranged Chapt 7 with OBAMA’s auto czars.. Looking at GM performance over the past several years, it seems these same much acclaimed MBA’s are still working there. I for one believe education is very important but, working knowledge of an operation is also VERY important..

    General Motors has discarded their salary retirees off to Prudential Insurance IRA. My belief is, GM continued robbing the salary pension fund (because they could) due to ongoing 10′s of billions in losses in their European operations and fear of German unions and their contracts with GM….

    So, I actually enjoyed most of my time both in the military and General Motors… The military back in the mid-late 1960′s did not provide much advancement past E6 so I opted out. I do wish I would have continued serving with the National Guard till I earned 20 as it would have enhanced my monthly income substantially. Combat Vets did not have to do any National Guard service back then so I opted out.

    I believe adults 18 years and older should have to serve in military service. Boot camp certainly wakes you up to being on YOUR OWN and Making it ON YOUR OWN quick….

    • Jackie says:

      Dear Anthony,

      Thank you for your service. I grew up in the 60′s and remember the Vietnam war. In fact my boyfriend also serviced
      Regarding your comment on GM and Obama. Who left office with this country on the verge of a depression in 2009?
      Bush was an awful president. At lest Obama saved GM even if you don’t agree on how he did it.

      Jackie

      • Laura R. Charron says:

        Anyone who thinks obama saved GM has no understanding of the car industry or of obama. The bailout delayed the inevitable. We will not be able to sustain their promises to their retirees, union or investors. Just like FDR, obama is prolonging a DEPRESSION. It took a world war to save us then. God help us if it takes another one.

        • Anthony Kirk says:

          Laura,
          Your right on about GM. Already they have thrown current active and retired salary employees under the bus. There is NO way GM will be able to pay UAW retirees full pension benefits so, down the road after the Nov 2012 election when time is right, GM will have figured a way to change / reduce UAW retiree pensions and benefits. GM still owes the taxpayers (us) 44 billion dollars. That’s 27 for GM and 17 for GMAC (now Ally). They are losing 10′s of billions yearly in their European operation and, pensions for all union members are underfunded. OBAMA ok’d car czars to use tax dollars to top up all union pensions in 2009 but GM is burning through cash as fast as OBAMA admInistration. Since GM is sitting pretty in China and currently profitable in North America, their mfg centers and R and D engineering is getting the cash to stay healthy. There is NO way GM can prop up the UAW pension underfunding and, no way will GM get another hand out when they are 44 billion in debt with no way to pay it back.

Speak Your Mind

*